Mobile Automation Testing Tools: Appium vs Selenium vs Calabash

Appium, Selenium, and Calabash are three of the most well-liked testing tools available. When selecting the ideal tool for your project, it is essential to understand how each one differs from the others because each one has unique strengths and limitations. In this blog post, we will compare Appium, Selenium, and Calabash. We will discuss their features, benefits, and drawbacks, to help you choose the right tool for your mobile app development project.

In today’s technologically advanced world, mobile app development is a vital part of business. It can be difficult to find the best automated testing solution for your project when there are so many options accessible to mobile app developers. Appium, Selenium, and Calabash are three of the most well-liked testing tools available. When selecting the ideal tool for your project, it is essential to understand how each one differs from the others because each one has unique strengths and limitations.


Introduction:

Automated testing tools have become a vital part of the mobile app development process.  They assist in finding mistakes and bugs, ensuring the applications dependability and quality. Yet, with the plethora of testing tools available in the market, choosing the ideal one for your project might be challenging.

In this blog post, we will compare three of the most popular testing tools in the market – Appium, Selenium, and Calabash. We will discuss their features, benefits, and drawbacks, to help you choose the right tool for your mobile app development project.


Appium:

Appium is an open-source test automation framework lets you test native, hybrid, and mobile web applications on iOS and Android devices. It supports a number of programming languages, including Java, Python, Ruby, and JavaScript, and communicates with the hardware through the WebDriver protocol.


Benefits of Appium:

Cross-platform Testing – Appium enables you to write tests once and run them on multiple platforms, including iOS and Android.

Supports Multiple Programming Languages – Appium supports several programming languages, making it easier for developers to write and execute tests.

Supports Cloud-based Testing – Testing on many platforms and devices is made simpler by the ability of Appium to interface with cloud-based testing providers like Sauce Labs and BrowserStack.

Image Comparison– Appium comes with built-in image comparison capability that may be used by developers to find visual regressions when testing.

Hybrid Application Testing-Appium is a good solution for testing sophisticated mobile applications because it offers testing for hybrid applications, which integrate web and native components.


Drawbacks of Appium:

Difficult Setup – Setting up Appium can be complicated, especially for new users.

Slow test execution – Appium can be slow to execute tests, especially when testing complex mobile applications.

Limited support for Non-native Apps – Appium does not support testing for  non-native apps like mobile gaming and augmented reality applications.

Want a brighter career as a software tester? check out Software Testing Course in Pune 

Book Your Time-slot for Counselling !


Selenium:

Selenium is a popular open-source, automated web application testing tool that supports several different programming languages, including Java, Python, Ruby, and C#. It enables programmers to automate web-based testing on many platforms and browsers.


Benefits of Selenium:

Cross-browser Testing – Selenium enables you to test your web application across a variety of platforms and browsers to make sure it is compatible with various devices.

Supports Multiple Programming Languages– Selenium is able to run tests written in a variety of languages, which is helpful for developers.

Integrates With Various Tools – Selenium integrates with various tools, including continuous integration systems, making it easier to automate the entire testing process.

Testing for Security Vulnerabilities – Selenium offers a mechanism to test for security vulnerabilities like SQL injection and cross-site scripting, which can help developers ensure the security of their web application.

Desktop Application Testing – Selenium is a flexible solution for cross-platform testing since it provides testing for desktop apps utilising frameworks like WinAppDriver and Appium for Windows.

Selenium Online Training


Drawbacks of Selenium:

Limited Support for Mobile Applications – Selenium does not have native support for mobile applications, making it challenging to test mobile applications without additional tools.

Inconsistent Test Results – Selenium can produce inconsistent test results due to variations in the browser’s behavior, making it challenging to pinpoint errors and bugs.

Slow Test Execution – Selenium can be slow to execute tests, especially when testing complex web applications.


Calabash:

Calabash is an open-source, cross-platform test automation tool that enables you to test native and hybrid mobile applications on iOS and Android devices. It supports a variety of programming languages, including Ruby and Cucumber, which makes it simple for developers to write and run tests.


Benefits of Calabash:

Cross-platform Testing- Using Calabash, you can write tests once and run them across other platforms, such as iOS and Android.

Supports Programming Languages – Calabash makes it simpler for developers to build and run tests by supporting programming languages like Ruby and Cucumber.

Supports Non-native Apps – Calabash’s support for non-native apps makes it possible to test them, including augmented reality software and mobile gaming.

Integrates With Various Tools– Calabash interfaces with a variety of tools, including as continuous integration systems and cloud-based testing services, making it simpler to automate the entire testing process.

Performance Testing-: Calabash provides a technique for gauging how quickly a given application reacts to user inputs in order to evaluate the performance of the application.

Check out Online Selenium Training. Enroll now!


Drawbacks of Calabash:

Limited Community Support – Compared to Appium and Selenium, Calabash has a smaller community, making it more difficult to locate answers to certain issues.

Slower Test Execution– Test execution can take longer using Calabash, especially when complicated mobile applications are being tested.

Limited Parallel Testing Support– Calabash provides limited parallel testing capabilities, making it difficult to execute several tests at once.

Meet the industry person, to clear your doubts !


What is Automated testing?

Automated testing is a software testing methodology that streamlines the process of verifying software functionality and compliance with requirements prior to commercial release. An organisation may conduct targeted software tests more quickly and without the need for human testers by using automated testing. Large or recurring test cases are the ideal candidates for automated testing.

Testing tools run predefined sequences as part of automated software testing. Software is tested, findings are reported, and results are compared with previous test runs using automated testing tools. You may develop an automated test script once and use it again and again.
Unit, programming interfaces (API), and regression testing are just a few of the many scenarios in which an organisation might use automated testing. The primary advantage of automated testing of software is in the reduction of manual labour into a collection of scripts. For instance, a group working on quality assurance (QA) should consider automating unit testing if it takes up a significant portion of their resources.

Software development processes that involve continuous testing, continuous integration (CI), and continuous delivery (CD) greatly benefit from the use of automated tests, which can be carried out frequently and at any time of day.

Why Automated Testing is required?

You might not be aware that new bugs that weren’t in prior versions of the programme could exist when fresh releases or bug patches are made. Checking the software as a whole is the best method to find out. There are undoubtedly many disadvantages to manual testing that may be addressed by automation. The following justifies the need for automated testing:

Automation testing allows for the absence of human interaction and allows for unattended test runs.
Testing multilingual websites by hand may be quite challenging.
Automation helps to boost test execution pace.
Errors won’t occur during automation testing.
Test coverage is increased in part by automation.

How it works?

The phases in the automated testing process often go like this:

Choose a tool for testing. This is contingent upon the kind of the testing being conducted and if the tool in question is compatible with the platform that the programme is being created for.
Describe the automation’s reach. This indicates the degree of automation used in software testing.
Arrange, create, and advance. Creating test scripts and organising the automation approach are part of this stage.
Carry out the examination. Automation scripts are used for software testing. Additionally, the testing tool need to gather information and offer thorough test findings.
upkeep. Automated test scripts are updated and changed in response to new software builds as needed.

Appium- Appium is a freely available and open source framework for evaluating user interfaces in mobile applications. Appium supports web, native, and hybrid application testing. Simulators, emulators, and actual devices can all be used for automation testing.

Calabash- Tests for iOS and Android apps may be created and run using the open-source Calabash testing framework. Tests developed in Cucumber and Ruby are supported by this Automated User Interface framework.



Similarities and Differences between Calabash and Appium

Mobile app testing is done using Appium and Calabash. While there are other web app testing tools available, these are the ones made especially for testing mobile apps. Both have a thriving and active community and are available as open source. This leads to frequent addition of new features and prompt issue fixes for both. Additionally, both of them are capable of testing any kind of mobile application created in any language.
The primary distinction is that Appium does automated testing, whereas Calabash conducts acceptance testing. Whereas Appium test cases may be created in a number of languages, including Java, JavaScript, and Python, Calabash test cases are written in English sentences using a language called Gherkin.


Appium vs Selenium vs Calabash:

When it comes to choosing between Appium, Selenium, and Calabash, there are several factors to consider. Here are some of the key differences between these three test automation frameworks:

Platform Support: Appium and Calabash support both Android and iOS platforms, while Selenium only supports web applications.

Language Support:Selenium supports the following programming languages: Java, Python, Ruby, and C#. Appium supports several of the same languages as Selenium does, along with PHP and JavaScript. It is necessary to be familiar with Ruby or another language that supports the Cucumber syntax in order to use Calabash.

Installation and Setup:Appium and Selenium may both be installed and configured without too much difficulty, although Calabash requires the installation of Ruby and its dependencies.

Test Creation:Appium and Selenium give developers a lot of options when it comes to developing tests by allowing them to utilise any testing framework of their choosing. Contrarily, Calabash makes use of the Cucumber syntax and demands an understanding of either Ruby or another language that does as well.

Test Execution:Appium and Calabash allow test execution on actual devices, whereas Selenium requires the usage of browser drivers. Yet, because Selenium provides cross-browser testing, it is a great choice for web applications.

Community support:Each of the three test automation frameworks has an active online community that contributes to tool development and support. However, because Selenium has the largest community, it also has the most resources and documentation.

Framework Support:Selenium, one of the first and most popular automated testing frameworks, has a large developer community that is constantly working to improve and add new features. In contrast, the communities for Appium and Calabash are a little bit smaller, so it is conceivable that you won’t discover as many ready-made solutions as you would for Selenium.

Testing Environment:Selenium is made for web applications, but Appium is made exclusively for testing mobile apps. Contrarily, Calabash can be used to test both web and mobile applications. Appium and Calabash are better options if testing for mobile applications is your primary priority. Selenium is the finest alternative if you want to test web applications.

Language Support:Selenium only supports a small number of programming languages, such as Java, Python, C#, and Ruby, in contrast to Appium, which supports Java, Python, Ruby, PHP, JavaScript, and C#. The only languages that Calabash supports are Ruby and Cucumber. Selecting a tool that is compatible with the programming language you are most accustomed to is essential.

Ease of Use:Selenium is a good option for beginners because it is relatively straightforward to use and has an easy-to-understand interface. Contrarily, the learning curve for Appium and Calabash is higher, and it could take some time to get acquainted to their user interfaces.

Performance:Selenium is well known for its great performance and is frequently used by businesses with extensive needs for test automation. Although Calabash and Appium have comparable performance metrics, there may be limitations when running several tests at once.

Enroll our Selenium classes in Pune and become an expert in Software Testing.


Appium, Selenium, And Calabash for Freshers And Experienced Professionals

Automation testing is an evolving field, and both freshers and experienced professionals need to keep up with the latest trends and technologies to ensure successful automation testing projects. For freshers, it is essential to start by understanding the basics of testing, programming, and automation concepts. They can then focus on learning one tool at a time, such as Appium, Selenium, or Calabash, and build a strong foundation before moving on to other tools.

Freshers can also gain practical experience by building simple automation frameworks and participating in forums, webinars, and meetups to gain knowledge and network with peers. It is also crucial to learn about different types of testing, test automation frameworks, and test management and defect tracking tools like JIRA or TestRail.

For experienced professionals, expanding their skillset by learning new automation testing tools and programming languages, such as Appium, Selenium, or Calabash, is essential. They should also focus on integrating automation testing with the overall software development lifecycle, including CI/CD processes. Learning about cloud-based testing and testing APIs is also important. Additionally, experienced professionals should contribute to the testing community by sharing their knowledge and experiences through blogs, forums, and mentoring freshers.

They should focus on building their leadership skills by taking ownership of projects and leading teams to successful project completion. Testing AI and machine learning algorithms is also an emerging area that requires specialized skills and knowledge.Networking with industry peers and attending conferences and seminars to stay current with the latest trends and developments to ensure successful automation testing projects.

Do you want to book a FREE Demo Session?



Conclusion:

In conclusion, selecting the right automated testing tool for your mobile app development project depends on various factors, such as the type of application, testing needs, and development team’s experience. Appium, Selenium, and Calabash are popular testing tools in the market, each with its own strengths and weaknesses. To master the skills from industry experts at 3RI Technologies.

If you are looking for a tool that supports cross-platform testing, cloud-based testing, and multiple programming languages, Appium is the best choice. However, if you are looking for a tool that supports cross-browser testing, integrates with various tools, and has a larger community, Selenium is a better option. On the other hand, if you are looking for a tool that supports non-native apps, has a simpler syntax, and supports parallel testing, Calabash is a suitable choice.

Choosing the right tool for automation testing depends on several factors such as project requirements, platform, application type, and team expertise. Newcomers to automation testing can start with Selenium since it has a lower learning curve and an extensive community to support. For experienced employees, Appium or Calabash can be a good choice based on the project requirements. Testers should also consider their team expertise and the available resources before selecting the tool.

In conclusion, the selection of the automation testing tool is crucial for efficient and effective testing. The right choice can improve the testing process, save time and cost, and increase the quality of the final product.

Leave a Reply

Share:

Blog Category

For Career Guidance

Connect with us

Batch Schedule

Schedule Your Batch

31-Mar-24 | SAT-SUN 8:00 AM to 10:00 AM

15-Apr-24 | MON-FRI 8:00 AM to 10:00 AM

28-Apr-24 | SAT-SUN 8:00 AM to 10:00 AM

Timings Doesn't Suit You ?

We can set up a batch at your convenient time.